Case study: negotiation

Morwell VIC: $34K under asking, valued $43K above the price paid

How we bought a renovated unit in Morwell for an investor: two rounds of negotiation, the checks we ran, and a tenant in place within about three weeks of settlement.

Citadel Agency · licensed buyers agency, licence 092247L
Renovated weatherboard unit with carport in Morwell VIC secured for a Citadel Agency client
Morwell, Latrobe Valley.
$446,000final price, asking price $480,000
$489,000valuation
$420 a weekrent, a 4.9% gross yield
About 3 weeksfrom settlement to a tenant
  1. Secured at $455,000$25,000 under the $480,000 asking price
  2. A further $9,000 offFinal price $446,000
  3. Leased at $420 a weekWithin about three weeks
In this case study 8 sections
  1. What did we buy?
  2. What was the brief?
  3. How did we negotiate the price?
  4. What did we check?
  5. What does it earn?
  6. What does it cost to hold?
  7. How did it lease so fast?
  8. What was the outcome?

We secured a recently renovated unit in Morwell for $455,000, which was $25,000 under its $480,000 asking price. After the building and pest inspection we negotiated a further $9,000 off, for a final price of $446,000. The unit was valued at $489,000 and leased at $420 a week within about three weeks of settlement.

Key points
  • Final price $446,000: $34,000 (7.1%) under the $480,000 asking price.
  • Valued at $489,000, which is $43,000 above the final price.
  • Leased at $420 a week, a 4.9% gross yield on the final price.
  • Tenant in place within about three weeks of settlement, helped by early access to the unit.

What did we buy?

WhereMorwell VIC
What3 bed, 1 bath, 2 car renovated villa unit
Paid$446,000
Rent$420 a week

A recently renovated townhouse style villa unit on a corner block, with a carport, in the Latrobe Valley: 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, 2 car spaces and 306m² of land. It was listed on the market at $480,000 and had other buyers interested.

Renovated kitchen in the Morwell VIC unit secured for a Citadel Agency clientBedroom in the renovated Morwell VIC unitRenovated bathroom with freestanding bath in the Morwell VIC unitAerial view of the renovated Morwell VIC unit with new fencing

Swipe or use the arrows to see more photos

What was the brief?

The client wanted a low maintenance investment where the rent does most of the work: an affordable price, a property that needs no work, and a tenant in place quickly.

How did we negotiate the price?

In two rounds, and without damaging the relationship with the selling agent.

  1. 1Asking price: $480,000The unit was listed on the open market with competing interest.
  2. 2Contract price: $455,000Strong terms, a competitive offer and our existing relationship with the agent secured it $25,000 (5.2%) under the asking price.
  3. 3A further $9,000 offWe used the building and pest review to negotiate a further reduction, for a final price of $446,000.
  4. 4Relationship kept intactWe pushed hard on price but stayed fair with the agent. That goodwill secured early access to the unit before settlement.

What did we check?

The unit was recently renovated, and the building and pest inspection found no issues.

  • Our own inspection, before the offer. We confirmed the quality of the renovation and how the unit presented.
  • Building and pest, during the contract period. No issues found. The review still supported a further price reduction.
  • Rental compliance, before settlement. Electrical, gas and smoke alarm checks were started early, so the unit could be leased straight away.

What does it earn?

The unit leased at $420 a week, which is $21,840 a year. On the final price of $446,000 that is a 4.9% gross yield. On the $455,000 contract price it would have been 4.8%.

Gross yield is the yearly rent divided by the purchase price, before costs such as rates, insurance, owners corporation fees and management.

What does it cost to hold?

Every dollar in and out for a year, before any loan costs.

Rent in, each year

$21,840

$420 a week

Council rates$1,200
Water rates$900
Insurance$1,000
Property management (5.5%)$1,201
Maintenance allowance$1,784
Left after costs, before the loan$15,755 a year
about $303 a week · 3.5% net yield

Costs are for this property. There is no owners corporation fee. The maintenance figure is an allowance, not a bill.

What would an interest only loan add?

Move the sliders to see the weekly interest on an interest only loan, and what is left or owing each week.

Loan amount$356,800
Interest a week$446
Rent left after costs$303
You would add each week$143

Illustration only. It uses the $446,000 price and the costs above, and shows interest only, with no loan fees or tax. It is not a quote, a rate forecast or credit advice. Citadel Agency is not a lender or a mortgage broker. Speak to a licensed broker about your own lending.

How did it lease so fast?

A tenant was in place within about three weeks of settlement. The selling agent gave us early access to the unit, so the rental compliance checks were done before settlement instead of after it. That saved roughly three weeks of vacancy, or about $1,260 in rent at $420 a week.

What was the outcome?

The client bought a renovated unit with a clear building and pest report for $446,000. That is $34,000 under the asking price and $43,000 under its $489,000 valuation. It was earning $420 a week within about three weeks of settlement.

  • Competitive terms. An offer the vendor could accept, at a price well under asking.
  • A strong agent relationship. Firm on price, fair in approach, which earned early access.
  • Checks that did real work. Due diligence that turned into a further price reduction.
Sources
  • Asking price, contract price, final price, valuation, rent and inspection results: Citadel Agency client records (suburb only, no client details).

General information only. It does not take your objectives, financial situation or needs into account. A valuation is an opinion of value at a point in time and values can fall as well as rise. Past results do not guarantee future results.

FAQ

Questions, answered

How much under the asking price was the Morwell unit bought?

The unit was listed at $480,000. The contract price was $455,000, and a further $9,000 came off after the building and pest inspection. The final price was $446,000, which is $34,000 or 7.1% under the asking price.

What was the Morwell unit valued at?

It was valued at $489,000, which is $43,000 above the final purchase price of $446,000.

What rental yield does the Morwell unit earn?

It leased at $420 a week, which is $21,840 a year. On the final price of $446,000 that is a 4.9% gross yield, before costs.

How quickly was the unit leased?

A tenant was in place within about three weeks of settlement. Early access to the unit before settlement meant the rental compliance checks were already done.

Want to build equity faster?A licensed buyers agent will look at your budget, borrowing and goals, and whether a renovation play fits.
Book a free strategy call